Andy Cohen has admitted that he likely favoured Bethenny Frankel over Carole Radziwill during their tense Season 10 reunion on The Real Housewives of New York City.
The Watch What Happens Live host looked back at the 2018 confrontation during an October 22 appearance on The Ringer’s Morally Corrupt podcast, where he reflected on his role in the argument and why his relationship with Carole had become strained.
When asked if he had taken Bethenny’s side, Andy acknowledged, “I probably did.” He also said he had not been as angry as viewers may have thought when Carole challenged him during the reunion.
Andy looks back at Bethenny and Carole’s RHONY reunion
Bethenny and Carole had been close friends before their relationship fell apart during Season 10. Their disagreement became one of the season’s biggest storylines, and the tension carried into the reunion.
Carole also questioned Andy’s closeness to Bethenny and suggested that Bethenny had influence over him.
Andy said Carole’s relationship with the show had changed by that point. He remembered that she was unhappy with the series and with him, which made their exchange more difficult.
Andy recalled that Carole had grown frustrated with the programme and with him personally, admitting that their relationship “got combative”.
He also addressed Carole’s claim about his loyalty, saying, “I really wasn’t” angry with her and adding, “I can take it.”
What happened between Bethenny Frankel and Carole Radziwill at the RHONY reunion?
Bethenny and Carole’s friendship fell apart during RHONY Season 10 in 2018.
Their disagreement became a major part of the season, with both women accusing each other of hurtful behaviour.
Carole also felt Andy was giving Bethenny more support during their arguments.

During Part 2 of the reunion, Carole challenged Andy’s handling of the situation. She questioned whether he was also afraid of Bethenny and accused him of taking her side.
The tension between Carole and Andy continued after the reunion.
Carole later criticised his comments about the argument, while Andy maintained that both women had spoken negatively about each other.
However, the two appeared together again at Bravo Fan Fest in Charleston on October 24, 2026.
Carole joined Andy’s Housewives History Lesson panel, where she was asked whether Bethenny could return to RHONY.
Carole said the decision was “way above my pay grade” before pointing to Andy as the person who could make that call.
Andy responded with a light-hearted comment about not being active on TikTok.
The Real Housewives of New York City airs on Bravo and streams on Peacock.
Want to CHATTR with us? Follow us on Instagram, Facebook and TikTok for more entertainment news.
