Exclusive: Big Brother's Matthew reveals who the real villain is this season and it's not who you think

"There’s a little bit of villain there, that smiling assassin."
Filed under news.
  • Matthew has revealed that Matty should be considered the real villain of the season.
  • The latest evictee said that his former housemate is hiding his true feelings in favour of being popular.
  • Matthew also agreed with Pheobe’s accusation that he caused a “great divide” in the house.
  • But he claimed the cliques already existed, he simply “fast-tracked” the separation.

Big Brother Australia 2026 housemate Matthew Karlsson has given us a peek behind the curtain at life in the house. 

While he may have gotten a bad wrap on screen as the villain, with former housemate Pheobe Joyce accusing him of causing a divide in the house, he tells Chattr in an exclusive chat that the real villain is someone fans probably aren’t expecting. 

Big Brother Australia 2026 evictee Matthew reveals who the real villain of the series is

When asked who the real villain of the series is, Matthew didn’t shy away from naming names, dobbing in one housemate in particular. 

“Maybe you could go with Matty,” he said. 

“He went strong at the start, going against the grain, and he sort of clawed it back. So maybe there’s a little bit of villain there, that smiling assassin.”

While he said that everyone he met through the experience “has a good heart”, he noted that the people flying under the radar are the ones to look out for. 

“Maybe [Matty] is doing the right things. He’s, I feel like, flip-flopping toward the popular vote always rather than really uncovering or showing who he really is,” Matthew said. 

Matty on Big Brother
Matty has been accused of being the house’s real villain. Image: Ten.

Matthew responds to Pheobe’s claims that he caused a ‘great divide’ in the Big Brother Australia house

Last week after being evicted from the Big Brother house, Phoebe accused Matthew of being the cause of a “great divide” in the house.

When asked if that was a fair statement, Matthew told Chattr, “Yeah, probably”. 

If he had to pinpoint the start of the divide, Matthew said it would have to come back to the “Maltesergate” situation. 

But, he said the divide was already naturally there, he simply “fast-tracked it”. 

Matthew explains how the cliques formed among the Big Brother Australia contestants

With contestants naturally gravitating toward certain people, Matthew explained what caused the divide from his perspective. 

Matthew
Matthew said he clocked a few people who weren’t being genuine inside the house. Image: Chattr.

“I think that Austin, Ebony and I… we were starting to get pretty frustrated that it’s a bit cringe, a bit of face value, you know that sort of stuff,” he said. 

He explained that the trio could see and feel people being fake, but didn’t have enough evidence to prove it to other housemates. 

“There’s a few things like, Marshy, he flip flops his opinion to suit the popular opinion. Then Heath and Tahlia are joint at the hip. Then there’s a brother-sister duo,” he said. 

“[The house] is sort of already a clique without it even being a clique, and it just took something as simple as [Maltesergate] to separate that.”

Big Brother airs 7:30pm weeknights and 7pm Sundays on 10, with the live stream available via 10 Play.

Want to CHATTR with us? Follow us on Instagram, Facebook and TikTok for more entertainment news.