Survivor 51‘s Kristin Flickinger has revealed a secret Tribal Council plan that could have saved her and Danny Kilby from their shock double elimination.
In a November 12 interview with TV Insider, Kristin explained how she nearly convinced immunity winners Sharonda Cox and Lewis Kelly to hand over their necklaces.
Kristin held a tethered immunity idol, but she couldn’t use it on herself while Sharonda remained in the game. Her plan was to have Sharonda and Lewis give their immunity necklaces to her and Kilby, then use the idol to protect the other pair.
All four players would have walked out of Tribal Council immune if the Hail Mary had worked, instead of Kristin and Kilby going home on a single vote after Jelly Loblack and Devin Way played an idol and Cristian Chavez hit his Shot in the Dark to save himself and Carter Krull.
How did Kristin’s secret Survivor 51 Tribal Council plan fall apart?
Kristin came up with the plan shortly before the cast left camp for Tribal Council and managed to signal Lewis about the necklace swap.
“Your necklace? Me?” she recalled asking him.
Lewis appeared interested and went to check with another contestant, but the tribe was called to Tribal Council before Kristin could approach Sharonda.
Once seated, Kristin leaned in low behind Maggie Nestor to pitch the swap directly to Sharonda, but Maggie overheard the whisper and shut it down on the spot.
“And at Tribal, you can see me leaning in really low, and I’m talking to Sharonda, and we’re whispering behind Maggie where I’m asking, ‘Girl, do you know what the mechanic is? Can you give me your necklace?’ And Maggie heard us, and Maggie perked up and said, ‘Don’t give her your necklace. Don’t you give that up.’ And she was like, ‘I would never give it up,'” Kristin recalled to TV Insider.
Host Jeff Probst quickly noticed the commotion and asked what was happening with the necklace.
“And then Jeff got involved, and it became this whole thing where I was like, ‘Nope, I’m not doing anything. Nothing to see here. I’m not a threat.’ So, I moved away from that plan and moved into, I guess, I’ll just solve it with a Shot in the Dark. And you see how that went,” she added.
Why Survivor 51’s Kristin Flickinger played her Shot in the Dark
After abandoning the necklace swap, Kristin played her Shot in the Dark in a bid to survive what she dubbed “Advantage-geddon 2.0”.
Kristin also revealed that she had planned to keep her Shot in the Dark result hidden if no other advantages came into play.
She didn’t want Jelly to realise she’d surrendered her vote, as Jelly believed they were still voting together.

“I didn’t want to reveal that I had surrendered my vote, so if nothing else had played, I would not have actually revealed my scroll. I would’ve kept it in my pocket. So, yes, I thought that there was a vote coming for me. Maybe two, probably one, maybe zero. I was about right, but it doesn’t make it any easier,” Kristin explained to TV Insider.
However, Kristin eventually realised her time on Survivor was over.
“I knew that it was me when I saw the colour of Cristian’s Shot in the Dark, the ribbon. It was different from mine. I knew that if one of us hit, one of us would not, so I knew it was coming,” she said.
Survivor 51 airs on Wednesdays at 8 pm ET/PT on CBS.
Want to CHATTR with us? Follow us on Instagram, Facebook and TikTok for more entertainment news.

