One of Strictly Come Dancing’s OG judges, Dame Arlene Phillips, has admitted she would “love to come back” to the ballroom panel, though she doubts the bosses would ever invite her back.
Despite rumours that current head judge Shirley Ballas may step down after a decade, Arlene remained realistic about her chances of reclaiming a seat.
Speaking to Digital Spy, she said, “I loved my time there, but I would never be asked.”
Arlene shared her fondness for the BBC reality TV series ahead of the November 26 cinema release of Starlight Express – Live On Stage, a production associated with her extensive choreography career.
She also compared the show’s format to its early days, when she judged alongside Len Goodman, Craig Revel Horwood and Bruno Tonioli.
Arlene Phillips says Strictly has lost some of its old charm
Beyond discussing a potential return, Arlene shared an honest assessment of the current season, which recently introduced new hosts Emma Willis, Johannes Radebe and Josh Widdicombe.
She then compared the modern era with the atmosphere during her stint on Strictly from 2004 to 2008.
“The first years I did the show, there was a lot of love, and the show wasn’t massive in the way it is now. Everybody loved Bruce,” Arlene explained, referring to the late original presenter Sir Bruce Forsyth.
“The new show hasn’t found its love yet and its true wonderful connection to the audiences at home. It’s not because there aren’t wonderful dancers, and some of the big numbers are phenomenal.”
In the same interview, Arlene also defended professional dancers Vito Coppola and Carlos Gu after former Strictly star James Jordan sparked backlash on X by claiming their same-sex results show duet was overly sexual for a family programme.
She urged critics to stop spreading negativity, adding, “Those views are of a time when you look back, and a lot of people regret it. We are now looking forward to the future, and what we need is to stop harassing something you don’t like. Keep it to yourself.”
Arlene has repeatedly voiced her willingness to return to Strictly
Arlene’s exit ahead of the 2009 series was one of the show’s most controversial moments, when BBC bosses replaced her with former winner Alesha Dixon.
She has previously expressed both affection for the programme and certainty that a permanent return is off the table, not only recently.
In August 2016, following news of Len Goodman’s departure, Arlene appeared on Good Morning Britain and expressed interest in filling the empty seat after seeing Olympic long jumper Greg Rutherford join the cast.
Later in 2021, while speaking to The Mirror, she revealed that producers never explained why they dismissed her in 2009. “I gave myself 48 hours to kick, scream, cry and sob, and eat scones with cream and jam, then I made myself wake up and get on with it,” she recalled back then.
By October 2022, Arlene told Express.co.uk that a comeback was off the table despite her fondness for the series. “It’s not a question I would ever ask myself because it’s not going to happen. So why even think about it?” she said.
She echoed that exact sentiment at the Pride of Britain Awards in October 2024, sharing, “I loved being on Strictly,” before adding, “They would never ask me, so I would never think about it. It’s not even an option.”
Strictly Come Dancing airs on BBC One and streams on BBC iPlayer.
Want to CHATTR with us? Follow us on Instagram, Facebook and TikTok for more entertainment news.

